7 Herbs That May Harm Your Liver: What to Know About Kava, Pennyroyal and Others

The growing popularity of herbal supplements has introduced many of us to the potential benefits of plant-based remedies. While many herbs offer genuine health advantages, some can pose serious risks to liver health when used incorrectly or by sensitive individuals. Your liver—the body's primary detoxification organ—processes everything you consume, including herbal supplements.

Understanding which herbs may potentially harm the liver is crucial for anyone interested in natural health approaches. This comprehensive guide examines seven herbs with documented liver concerns, from the widely known kava to the less familiar germander. We'll explore the scientific evidence behind these concerns, risk factors, and signs that might indicate liver stress.

Most importantly, we'll also discuss safer alternatives and liver-supportive options, including carefully formulated supplements designed specifically to promote liver health rather than compromise it. Whether you're a long-time herbal supplement user or just beginning to explore natural remedies, this information will help you make informed decisions about your liver health.

Understanding Liver Health and Herbal Risks

Your liver is remarkable—it filters toxins, produces essential proteins, stores vitamins, and processes nutrients from everything you consume. This vital organ has an impressive ability to regenerate and heal, but it's not invincible. When exposed to certain compounds, including some found in herbs and supplements, liver cells can become damaged or inflamed.

Herbal supplements, while often perceived as universally safe due to their "natural" status, contain bioactive compounds that can affect liver function. Several factors influence how herbs might impact your liver health:

• Individual biochemistry - Genetic factors can make some people more susceptible to herb-induced liver injury
• Pre-existing liver conditions - Those with hepatitis, cirrhosis, or other liver issues face higher risks
• Dosage and duration - Higher doses and extended use increase potential risks
• Quality and purity - Contaminated or misidentified herbs pose additional dangers
• Interactions - Combining herbs with medications or alcohol can amplify liver stress

The herbs we'll discuss have varying levels of research supporting their potential liver risks. Some have substantial clinical evidence documenting adverse effects, while others have more limited case reports. It's important to approach this information with a balanced perspective—understanding potential risks without dismissing potential benefits that these herbs might offer when used appropriately.

Kava: Traditional Use vs. Liver Concerns

Kava (Piper methysticum) has been used for centuries throughout the Pacific Islands as a ceremonial and social drink known for promoting relaxation and reducing anxiety. The herb gained popularity in Western countries as a natural alternative to anti-anxiety medications, with research supporting its effectiveness for anxiety relief.

However, kava's reputation became complicated in the early 2000s when several cases of severe liver damage—including some requiring liver transplantation—were reported in Europe and later in other regions. This led to bans or restrictions in several countries, though some have since been lifted as new research emerged.

What the Science Says About Kava

The exact mechanism behind kava's potential liver toxicity remains incompletely understood. Several theories exist:

• Inappropriate parts of the plant being used (stem and leaves instead of root)
• Extraction methods using alcohol or acetone instead of traditional water extraction
• Genetic variations making some users more susceptible
• Potential contamination or adulteration of commercial products

More recent research suggests that water-extracted kava root prepared in the traditional manner may pose significantly lower risks than some commercial formulations. Nevertheless, caution is warranted, particularly for individuals with existing liver conditions, those taking medications processed by the liver, or people who consume alcohol regularly.

Pennyroyal: A Potent Herb with Serious Risks

Pennyroyal (Mentha pulegium and Hedeoma pulegioides) has a long history of traditional use, primarily as an insect repellent and for addressing digestive complaints. It has also been historically—and dangerously—used as an abortion-inducing agent.

Of all the herbs on our list, pennyroyal presents some of the most serious documented risks. The herb contains pulegone, a compound that metabolizes in the liver to form highly toxic substances. These metabolites can cause severe, sometimes fatal liver and kidney damage, even in relatively small doses.

Documented Cases and Warnings

Multiple fatalities and serious injuries have been documented from pennyroyal ingestion, particularly from concentrated pennyroyal oil. As little as one teaspoon of the essential oil has proven fatal in some cases. Even tea made from the herb contains enough pulegone to cause concern, especially if consumed regularly or in large amounts.

Medical authorities and herbal safety experts universally recommend avoiding internal use of pennyroyal in any form. The risks far outweigh any potential benefits, and safer alternatives exist for all its traditional uses.

Comfrey: Historical Uses and Modern Cautions

Comfrey (Symphytum officinale) has been used for centuries as a healing herb, particularly for bone and wound healing—reflected in its traditional names like "knitbone" and "bruisewort." The plant contains allantoin, a compound that promotes cell proliferation and wound healing when applied topically.

However, comfrey also contains pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs), compounds now known to cause veno-occlusive disease, a serious condition where blood vessels in the liver become blocked. This can lead to liver damage, cirrhosis, and potential liver failure with continued exposure.

Internal vs. External Use

The scientific consensus has shifted firmly against internal use of comfrey. The German Commission E, the United Kingdom, Australia, and Canada have all restricted oral comfrey products. The FDA has also issued warnings about the internal use of comfrey and requested removal of comfrey products intended for internal use from the market.

External use presents a more nuanced picture. While PAs can be absorbed through the skin, especially on broken skin, the risk is considered substantially lower than with internal use. Some countries permit limited external application of comfrey with restrictions on PA content and duration of use. Even for topical application, alternatives without known liver risks may be preferable for many people.

Germander: From Remedy to Risk Factor

Germander (Teucrium species) has been used in traditional medicine systems for centuries, primarily for digestive complaints, gout, and as a component in weight loss formulations. In the late 1980s and early 1990s, germander gained popularity in France as a weight loss aid until multiple cases of hepatitis were linked to its use.

The hepatotoxicity of germander is attributed to its neo-clerodane diterpenoids, which are converted to toxic metabolites in the liver. These compounds can damage liver cells through multiple mechanisms, including depleting glutathione (a major antioxidant) and forming protein adducts that trigger immune responses.

Recognition and Regulation

After several documented cases of liver injury, including some that progressed to cirrhosis, France banned the use of germander in supplements in 1992. Other countries have since implemented similar restrictions. The concerning aspect of germander toxicity is that it can cause liver damage that mimics viral hepatitis and can progress even after discontinuing the herb if use was prolonged.

Studies have shown that liver damage from germander can be dose-dependent and sometimes delayed, appearing only after weeks or months of regular use. Due to these concerns and the availability of safer alternatives for its traditional uses, germander is generally not recommended for medicinal purposes.

Greater Celandine: Traditional Medicine with Liver Implications

Greater celandine (Chelidonium majus) is a member of the poppy family with a long history of use in European and Chinese traditional medicine. It has been primarily used for gallbladder and liver complaints, digestive disorders, and topically for skin conditions including warts.

The irony of greater celandine is that despite being traditionally used to treat liver and gallbladder problems, it has been associated with numerous cases of liver injury. The plant contains various alkaloids, including chelidonine and sanguinarine, which appear to be responsible for its potential hepatotoxic effects.

Evidence of Liver Concerns

Multiple case reports and case series have documented greater celandine-induced liver injury, with patterns ranging from acute hepatitis to cholestatic hepatitis (affecting bile flow). The European Medicines Agency and regulatory bodies in several countries have issued warnings about its potential liver risks.

Reactions to greater celandine appear to be idiosyncratic, meaning they don't affect all users and aren't strictly dose-dependent. This unpredictability makes it difficult to establish safe usage guidelines. Liver function typically improves after discontinuing the herb, though complete resolution may take weeks to months in severe cases.

Chaparral: Desert Herb with Hidden Dangers

Chaparral (Larrea tridentata), also known as creosote bush or greasewood, is native to the deserts of the southwestern United States and Mexico. Indigenous peoples have traditionally used it for various conditions, including arthritis, cancer, and infections. In the 1970s and 1980s, chaparral gained popularity as an alternative cancer treatment and antioxidant supplement.

The main active compound in chaparral is nordihydroguaiaretic acid (NDGA), which does indeed have antioxidant and potential anti-cancer properties in laboratory studies. However, NDGA has also been implicated in the herb's potential liver toxicity.

From Folk Remedy to FDA Warning

After multiple case reports of acute non-viral hepatitis and even liver failure requiring transplantation were linked to chaparral use, the FDA issued warnings about its potential dangers in 1992. The herb was subsequently removed from most commercial products, though it remains available from some suppliers.

Liver reactions to chaparral appear to be idiosyncratic and can occur after varying periods of use, from weeks to months. The severity ranges from mild enzyme elevations to severe acute hepatitis and, rarely, liver failure. Most cases resolve after discontinuation, but the unpredictable nature of the reaction and potential severity argue strongly for avoiding this herb when alternatives exist.

Skullcap: Separating Benefits from Concerns

Skullcap (Scutellaria species) has been used in both Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine for anxiety, insomnia, and inflammation. American skullcap (Scutellaria lateriflora) and Chinese skullcap (Scutellaria baicalensis) are the most commonly used varieties, with somewhat different traditional applications and constituent profiles.

The liver concerns surrounding skullcap have a complicated history. Several cases of hepatotoxicity were attributed to skullcap in the 1980s and 1990s, but later investigations revealed that many commercial "skullcap" products were actually adulterated with germander (which we've already identified as hepatotoxic) or other Teucrium species.

Quality and Identification Issues

Pure, correctly identified skullcap has fewer documented liver concerns than many other herbs on this list. However, the historical adulteration issues highlight a critical concern with herbal supplements in general: the importance of proper identification and quality control.

Modern research on authentic skullcap species suggests potential hepatoprotective effects rather than toxicity, particularly for Chinese skullcap. Nevertheless, caution is warranted, and purchasing from reputable companies with rigorous quality testing is essential if you choose to use skullcap products.

Signs Your Liver May Be Compromised

Recognizing potential liver problems early is crucial, as many liver conditions can be addressed effectively if caught before significant damage occurs. If you're using herbal supplements, particularly any mentioned in this article, be vigilant for these warning signs:

• Jaundice - Yellowing of the skin or whites of the eyes
• Abdominal pain or swelling - Particularly in the upper right area
• Unusual fatigue or weakness - Persistent and not explained by other factors
• Nausea or vomiting - Especially if persistent
• Dark urine - Not related to dehydration or foods
• Pale stools - Clay-colored rather than normal brown
• Itchy skin - Without rash or obvious cause
• Easy bruising - Occurring without significant injury

If you experience any of these symptoms, especially after starting a new supplement or herbal product, discontinue use immediately and consult a healthcare professional. Prompt medical attention is essential, as liver damage can progress rapidly in some cases.

Liver-Supportive Herbs and Ingredients

While some herbs pose risks to liver health, others have demonstrated protective or supportive effects. These botanicals, many with centuries of traditional use and modern research validation, can be part of a liver-friendly wellness approach:

Milk Thistle (Silymarin)

Perhaps the most well-researched liver-supportive herb, milk thistle contains silymarin, a compound shown to help protect liver cells from toxins and promote regeneration of liver tissue. Its antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties make it beneficial for various liver conditions.

QN Wellness' Liver-Care Pro™ includes silymarin as a primary ingredient, recognizing its importance in liver health support. The silymarin in Liver-Care Pro™ works to protect liver cells from damage while supporting their natural regeneration process.

Schisandra

This berry from Traditional Chinese Medicine has adaptogenic properties and contains lignans that support liver detoxification pathways. Research suggests schisandra can help normalize liver enzyme levels and protect against various liver injuries.

Liver-Care Pro™ incorporates schisandra as one of its key ingredients, leveraging its protective benefits for liver function and overall detoxification support.

Bupleurum

Used extensively in Asian traditional medicine systems, bupleurum has demonstrated anti-inflammatory and hepatoprotective properties. It helps modulate immune function and may support healthy bile flow.

Another important component in Liver-Care Pro™, bupleurum complements the formula's other ingredients to promote comprehensive liver support.

Salvia (Chinese Sage)

Not to be confused with common culinary sage, Chinese salvia (Salvia miltiorrhiza or red sage) contains compounds that support circulation to the liver and have antioxidant properties beneficial for liver health.

This traditional herb rounds out the formulation of Liver-Care Pro™, providing additional antioxidant support for liver function.

Oleanolic Acid

This naturally occurring triterpenoid compound has been shown to have hepatoprotective effects. Research suggests it can help protect against chemical-induced liver injury and support healthy liver function.

As a key ingredient in Liver-Care Pro™, oleanolic acid works synergistically with the other components to provide comprehensive liver support.

Protecting Your Liver: Best Practices

Beyond avoiding potentially harmful herbs, there are several proactive steps you can take to support your liver health:

1. Limit alcohol consumption - Alcohol is a well-established liver toxin when consumed in excess
2. Maintain a healthy weight - Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease is increasingly common and linked to obesity
3. Eat a liver-friendly diet - Rich in vegetables, fruits, whole grains, and healthy fats
4. Stay hydrated - Proper hydration supports overall detoxification
5. Exercise regularly - Physical activity helps maintain healthy liver function
6. Avoid unnecessary medications - Many drugs are processed by the liver; take only what's necessary
7. Consider liver-supportive supplements - Products like Liver-Care Pro™ contain ingredients specifically chosen to support liver health

When using supplements, always choose products from reputable companies that prioritize quality control and testing. QN Wellness maintains rigorous standards for their vegetarian supplement formulations, ensuring you receive the benefits of traditional herbs without unnecessary risks.

Conclusion

The relationship between herbs and liver health illustrates an important principle in natural medicine: natural doesn't automatically mean safe in all contexts. The herbs discussed in this article—kava, pennyroyal, comfrey, germander, greater celandine, chaparral, and skullcap—all have documented concerns regarding liver health that merit careful consideration.

This doesn't mean all herbal supplements pose liver risks. Many herbs, particularly those included in well-formulated products like Liver-Care Pro™ from QN Wellness, have demonstrated protective and supportive effects on liver function. The key lies in informed selection, appropriate use, and quality sourcing.

When approaching herbal supplements:

• Research thoroughly before trying new herbs
• Purchase from reputable companies with quality testing protocols
• Consider consulting with healthcare providers knowledgeable about herbs
• Be particularly cautious if you have existing liver conditions
• Pay attention to how your body responds

Your liver performs hundreds of essential functions daily. Treating it with respect—by avoiding potentially harmful substances and supporting its function with appropriate nutrition and supplements—is an investment in your long-term health and wellbeing.

Support Your Liver Health Naturally

QN Wellness's Liver-Care Pro™ combines silymarin, oleanolic acid, bupleurum, schisandra, and salvia—five powerful ingredients scientifically recognized for their liver-supportive properties. This vegetarian formula was specifically designed to promote healthy liver function and natural detoxification processes.

Explore QN Wellness Products