Elderberry for Cold Prevention: What Human Clinical Trials Reveal

As cold and flu season approaches, many of us seek natural remedies to bolster our immune defenses and minimize the impact of seasonal illnesses. Among the various natural options available, elderberry (Sambucus nigra) has emerged as a popular choice with a long history of traditional use. But does science support these traditional claims?

At QN Wellness, we believe in providing evidence-based information about natural remedies. This comprehensive review examines what human clinical trials tell us about elderberry's effectiveness in preventing colds and reducing their duration and severity. By analyzing the scientific evidence, we aim to provide you with reliable information to make informed decisions about incorporating elderberry into your wellness routine.

From controlled clinical studies to meta-analyses, we'll explore the scientific consensus on elderberry's immune-supporting properties, how it compares to other natural supplements, and what you should know about its safety profile. Whether you're looking to strengthen your immune system or seeking additional support during cold and flu season, this evidence-based review will help you understand what elderberry can—and cannot—do for your health.

What is Elderberry?

Elderberry refers to several varieties of the Sambucus tree, with Sambucus nigra (European elder or black elderberry) being the most commonly studied for health benefits. These dark purple berries have been used in traditional medicine across many cultures for centuries, particularly in Europe and North America.

The berries contain a variety of bioactive compounds that contribute to their potential health benefits, including:

• Anthocyanins – powerful antioxidants that give elderberries their deep purple color
• Flavonoids – plant compounds with anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects
• Vitamins A and C – essential nutrients that support immune function
• Potassium, iron, and other minerals – important for overall health and wellness

Elderberries should never be consumed raw, as uncooked berries, bark, and leaves contain a chemical that can cause nausea, vomiting, and other adverse effects. Commercial elderberry products are properly processed to eliminate these compounds, making them safe for consumption.

How Elderberry Works Against Colds

Understanding the mechanisms behind elderberry's potential effects on colds and flu helps explain the results seen in clinical trials. Research suggests elderberry works through several complementary pathways:

Antiviral Properties

Laboratory studies have demonstrated that elderberry extracts can inhibit the replication of certain viruses, including some strains of influenza. Specifically, compounds in elderberry appear to block viral proteins responsible for attachment and entry into host cells, effectively preventing the virus from spreading.

A 2019 study published in the Journal of Functional Foods found that elderberry inhibited the early stages of influenza infection by blocking the virus from attaching to and entering human cells, suggesting why it might be effective in reducing the duration of symptoms.

Immune System Support

Elderberry appears to modulate the immune system by stimulating the production of cytokines—proteins that serve as messengers between cells, helping to coordinate immune responses. This immunomodulatory effect may help the body respond more effectively to viral challenges.

Research has shown that elderberry extract increases the production of inflammatory cytokines, which play important roles in the body's defense against pathogens. This immune-stimulating activity may contribute to elderberry's potential protective effects against respiratory infections.

Antioxidant and Anti-inflammatory Effects

The high concentration of anthocyanins and other flavonoids in elderberry provides significant antioxidant capacity. These compounds help neutralize free radicals and reduce oxidative stress, which can occur during viral infections and contribute to tissue damage.

Additionally, elderberry has demonstrated anti-inflammatory properties in several studies. Since excessive inflammation can worsen cold and flu symptoms, this anti-inflammatory action may help alleviate symptoms and promote recovery.

Key Human Clinical Trials on Elderberry

While laboratory studies provide valuable insights into how elderberry might work, human clinical trials offer the most relevant evidence for its effectiveness in preventing and treating colds and flu. Here's a chronological review of significant human trials:

The Zakay-Rones Study (2004)

One of the most frequently cited elderberry studies was conducted by Dr. Zakay-Rones and colleagues, published in the Journal of International Medical Research. This randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study involved 60 patients (aged 18-54) suffering from influenza-like symptoms for 48 hours or less.

Participants received either 15ml of elderberry syrup or placebo four times daily for five days. The results showed that the elderberry group experienced relief from symptoms an average of four days earlier than the placebo group. Additionally, the elderberry group required significantly less rescue medication (pain relievers, decongestants) than those receiving placebo.

The Tiralongo Air Traveler Study (2016)

This randomized, double-blind placebo-controlled trial published in Nutrients investigated whether elderberry could prevent respiratory symptoms in air travelers. The study involved 312 economy class passengers traveling from Australia to an overseas destination.

Participants took elderberry extract (or placebo) from 10 days before travel until 4-5 days after arriving at their destination. The elderberry group reported:

• Fewer cold episodes than the placebo group
• Shorter duration of cold symptoms (average of 2 days shorter)
• Less severe symptoms when they did get sick

This study is particularly interesting as it examined elderberry's preventive effects rather than treatment after symptoms appeared.

The Hawkins Study (2019)

A more recent study published in Complementary Therapies in Medicine involved 87 participants with confirmed cases of influenza A or B. Participants received either a 15ml dose of elderberry syrup or placebo four times daily for five days.

This study found that the elderberry group recovered from influenza an average of 4 days faster than the placebo group. Additionally, the elderberry group reported significantly milder symptoms and reduced use of rescue medication.

Meta-Analysis by Harnett (2020)

A comprehensive meta-analysis published in Advances in Integrative Medicine analyzed data from multiple randomized controlled trials involving elderberry for respiratory symptoms. The analysis included 180 participants and found that elderberry supplements significantly reduced upper respiratory symptoms.

The researchers concluded that "supplementation with elderberry was found to substantially reduce upper respiratory symptoms." They noted that the commercial elderberry products used in these studies are generally well-tolerated and that side effects were rare.

Analysis of Elderberry's Effectiveness

When examining the body of human clinical research on elderberry, several patterns emerge regarding its effectiveness for cold and flu prevention and treatment:

Strengths of the Evidence

The human trials consistently show that elderberry supplementation can reduce the duration of cold and flu symptoms by an average of 2-4 days compared to placebo. This is a clinically significant reduction that improves quality of life during illness.

Multiple studies have demonstrated that elderberry can reduce symptom severity, particularly for nasal congestion, sore throat, and cough. This symptomatic relief appears to be most pronounced when elderberry is taken within the first 48 hours of symptom onset.

The preventive effects seen in the air traveler study suggest that elderberry may have protective benefits when taken before exposure to pathogens, though more research is needed to confirm this effect in other settings.

Limitations and Research Gaps

Despite promising results, there are several limitations in the current research:

Most studies have relatively small sample sizes (typically fewer than 100 participants), which limits the statistical power of their findings. Larger trials would provide more definitive evidence of elderberry's effects.

The studies use different elderberry preparations (syrups, lozenges, capsules) with varying concentrations of active compounds, making direct comparisons challenging. Standardization of elderberry extracts would help clarify optimal dosing.

More long-term studies are needed to assess elderberry's effectiveness for ongoing prevention throughout cold and flu season, rather than just for acute treatment or short-term travel scenarios.

Scientific Consensus

Based on the available human clinical trials, the scientific consensus suggests that elderberry supplements:

May reduce the duration of cold and flu symptoms by 2-4 days when taken promptly after symptom onset

Can decrease the severity of upper respiratory symptoms, particularly congestion, sore throat, and cough

Might offer preventive benefits when taken prior to pathogen exposure, though more research is needed

Are generally safe and well-tolerated when commercially prepared and taken as directed

While these findings are promising, it's important to note that elderberry should be viewed as a complementary approach to conventional cold and flu prevention strategies, such as hand washing, avoiding close contact with ill individuals, and following public health recommendations.

Safety Profile and Potential Side Effects

Understanding the safety profile of elderberry supplements is essential for making informed health decisions. The clinical trials we've reviewed provide valuable information about elderberry's tolerability, and additional research has examined potential risks and contraindications.

General Safety Profile

Commercially prepared elderberry supplements have demonstrated a strong safety profile in clinical trials. In the studies reviewed, adverse events were rare and generally mild, with no significant difference in side effect rates between elderberry and placebo groups.

The European Food Safety Authority and other regulatory bodies consider properly prepared elderberry products safe for consumption. This safety record applies specifically to commercially prepared elderberry products that have undergone appropriate processing to remove potentially harmful compounds.

Potential Side Effects

Though uncommon, some individuals may experience:

• Mild gastrointestinal effects (nausea, vomiting, or diarrhea)
• Allergic reactions (particularly in individuals with known allergies to plants in the Adoxaceae family)

It's crucial to emphasize that raw, unripe, or unprocessed elderberries contain lectins that can cause nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea. The stems, leaves, and bark contain cyanogenic glycosides, which can release cyanide when consumed. Commercial elderberry products eliminate these compounds through proper processing.

Special Considerations and Contraindications

Certain populations should exercise caution with elderberry supplements:

Pregnant and breastfeeding women: Limited research exists on elderberry safety during pregnancy and lactation. These groups should consult healthcare providers before using elderberry supplements.

Individuals with autoimmune conditions: Because elderberry may stimulate immune function, people with autoimmune disorders should consult their healthcare provider before use.

Those taking immunosuppressants: Elderberry's immune-stimulating properties could potentially interfere with immunosuppressive medications, although direct evidence of interactions is limited.

People with diabetes: Elderberry may affect blood sugar levels, so diabetics should monitor their glucose carefully if taking elderberry supplements.

As with any supplement, it's advisable to consult with a healthcare provider before beginning elderberry supplementation, especially for individuals with underlying health conditions or those taking medications.

Recommended Usage and Dosage

Based on the clinical trials reviewed, certain patterns emerge regarding effective elderberry supplementation strategies. While optimal dosing may vary by individual and specific product formulation, the following guidelines reflect current evidence:

Effective Dosing from Clinical Studies

The most consistent results in clinical trials came from these dosing approaches:

For acute treatment (after symptoms appear): Most successful studies used elderberry syrup at a dose of 15ml taken four times daily for 5 days.

For prevention: The air traveler study used elderberry extract tablets (300mg) taken twice daily for 10 days before travel and continued 4-5 days after arrival.

Commercial elderberry products come in various forms, each with different bioavailability and concentration of active compounds:

• Syrups: Most extensively studied in clinical trials, typically containing concentrated elderberry juice with added sweeteners
• Capsules and tablets: Convenient form containing dried elderberry extract in standardized doses
• Lozenges: Formulated for throat comfort in addition to systemic effects
• Gummies: Popular form especially for those who dislike pills, but may contain added sugars

Timing Considerations

The timing of elderberry supplementation appears important for maximizing benefits:

For treatment: Studies show best results when elderberry is started within the first 48 hours of symptom onset. Delaying supplementation may reduce effectiveness.

For prevention: Limited evidence suggests beginning supplementation 10-14 days before expected exposure (such as travel or the start of cold season) may be beneficial.

Duration: Most treatment studies continued elderberry supplementation for 5-7 days. For prevention, the optimal duration remains unclear, though the air traveler study suggests benefits from short-term preventive use (2-3 weeks).

Combining with Other Immune Support

Many people seek comprehensive immune support, especially during cold and flu season. Elderberry can complement other evidence-based approaches to immune health.

For individuals interested in comprehensive immune support, products like Immune Care™ from QN Wellness provide additional support with key ingredients like Vitamin C, Garlic Extract, and Propolis—all known for their immune-supporting properties. The combination of these ingredients with proper elderberry supplementation may offer synergistic benefits, though specific combination studies are limited.

It's important to note that elderberry supplementation should complement, not replace, basic health practices like adequate sleep, regular exercise, proper hydration, and a nutrient-rich diet.

Elderberry vs. Other Natural Cold Prevention Supplements

To provide context for elderberry's effectiveness, it's helpful to compare it with other popular natural supplements used for cold and flu prevention and treatment. This comparison can help individuals make informed choices about which supplements might best suit their needs.

Vitamin C

Vitamin C is perhaps the most well-known supplement for immune support. Multiple meta-analyses suggest that regular vitamin C supplementation does not prevent colds in the general population but may reduce cold duration by about 8% in adults and 14% in children. While this effect is modest, vitamin C has an excellent safety profile and provides additional health benefits.

For targeted immune support, QN Wellness's Immune Care™ contains Vitamin C along with Garlic Extract and Propolis, offering a well-rounded approach to immune health.

Zinc

Zinc lozenges or syrup, when taken within 24 hours of symptom onset, can reduce cold duration by 1-2 days. The effectiveness appears dependent on the zinc formulation and dose. Side effects can include nausea and unpleasant taste.

While QN Wellness doesn't offer a dedicated zinc supplement, zinc lactate is present in their Cool Beauty™ formulation, which primarily supports skin health but may offer additional benefits through its zinc content.

Echinacea

Research on echinacea shows mixed results. Some studies suggest it may reduce the risk of developing a cold by 10-20% and slightly decrease duration, but the evidence is inconsistent due to varying echinacea preparations and study methodologies.

Propolis

Propolis, a resin-like material made by bees, has shown promising results in some trials for reducing the incidence and duration of upper respiratory tract infections. Its effectiveness is attributed to its antimicrobial and immunomodulatory properties.

QN Wellness incorporates propolis in their Immune Care™ and Immune Care™ / Omega-Tree™ formulations, leveraging its potential benefits for immune support alongside other evidence-based ingredients.

Garlic

Limited evidence suggests that garlic may help prevent colds and reduce their duration. One notable study found that participants taking garlic supplements for 12 weeks had fewer colds than a placebo group, with shorter duration of symptoms when they did get sick.

Garlic extract is a key ingredient in Immune Care™ from QN Wellness, where it works synergistically with other immune-supporting ingredients like Vitamin C and propolis.

Comparative Analysis

When comparing elderberry to these other supplements based on current evidence:

• Symptom duration reduction: Elderberry appears to offer one of the most substantial reductions in symptom duration (2-4 days) compared to other natural options
• Preventive effects: Evidence for elderberry's preventive effects is promising but limited to fewer studies than some other supplements like vitamin C
• Symptom severity: Elderberry shows strong evidence for reducing symptom severity, comparable to or better than alternatives
• Safety profile: Commercial elderberry preparations have an excellent safety record, similar to vitamin C and most other natural options

For comprehensive immune support, many individuals choose to combine several evidence-based supplements. Products like Immune Care™ from QN Wellness offer multiple immune-supporting ingredients in a single formulation, which may provide complementary benefits through different mechanisms of action.

Conclusion

The body of human clinical research on elderberry for cold prevention and treatment presents a compelling case for its inclusion in a comprehensive approach to seasonal wellness. The most robust studies consistently demonstrate that elderberry can reduce the duration of cold and flu symptoms by an average of 2-4 days when taken promptly after symptom onset, with additional benefits for symptom severity.

While more research is still needed—particularly larger-scale studies and trials examining long-term preventive use—the existing evidence supports elderberry as one of the more promising natural options for addressing upper respiratory infections. Its multiple mechanisms of action, including antiviral effects, immune modulation, and anti-inflammatory properties, provide a scientific rationale for the benefits observed in clinical settings.

For those seeking natural immune support, elderberry represents a well-studied option with a strong safety profile when used as directed. Commercial elderberry products, properly processed to remove potentially harmful compounds, offer a convenient way to access these benefits.

As with any supplement approach, elderberry works best as part of a holistic wellness strategy that includes proper nutrition, adequate sleep, regular exercise, and good hygiene practices. For those looking for comprehensive immune support, combining elderberry with other evidence-based supplements like those found in Immune Care™ from QN Wellness may provide complementary benefits through different mechanisms of action.

Always consult with a healthcare provider before beginning any new supplement regimen, especially for individuals with underlying health conditions, those taking medications, or special populations such as pregnant or breastfeeding women.

Support your immune system naturally with QN Wellness

Looking for plant-based supplements to support your immune health? Explore our Immune Care™ with Vitamin C, Garlic Extract, and Propolis to help maintain your immune system's natural defenses year-round.

Shop QN Wellness Products